Loyalty Points Redemption: Why Members Want Travel, Not Merchandise
Somewhere in your program right now is a branded travel mug priced at 4,000 points. It has been there since launch. Nobody has redeemed it since launch.
Most points catalogs are less a rewards store than a storage unit. Gift cards, drinkware, a Bluetooth speaker from a brand nobody recognizes. Members browse once, do the math, and close the tab.
Meanwhile the thing they actually want to spend loyalty points on isn't in the catalog at all.
Expedia Group's Traveler Value Index 2025, based on 11,000 respondents across 11 markets, found that travel is "the top category consumers are interested in redeeming loyalty points for.” 83% expressed interest, against 40% for gift cards or cashback. It isn't close, and it hasn't been close for a while.
Key Takeaways
- Travel outranks every other redemption category, with 83% of consumers interested in redeeming loyalty points for it, compared with 40% for gift cards or cashback.
- More than four in five consumers say they'd be interested in booking travel through a non-travel loyalty program they already belong to.
- Gift cards and merchandise invite a cash-value comparison most programs lose. Travel gets measured against not taking the trip at all, which is a comparison programs win.
- Members trust a non-travel provider backed by a well-known travel brand more than an unfamiliar one, so travel redemption works best under a name members already know.2
- Hotel brands have repositioned points as a demand driver rather than a rebate, with loyalty program membership growing 14.5% in 2024 according to CBRE.
- Hilton reports that 58% of members use points to try properties, activities, and destinations they wouldn't otherwise book.
- Redemption friction is the quiet killer: 40% of loyalty members admit they sometimes forget to redeem at all.
What Members Actually Want to Redeem Loyalty Points For
When Expedia Group asked consumers what they want to redeem against, the ranking wasn't a photo finish. Travel came in at 83%. Gift cards or cashback took 40%. Merchandise and retail, 30%. Statement credit, 26%. Charitable contributions, 14%.2
Travel points redemption sits at roughly double the interest of the next category down, and the next category down is the one most non-travel programs have built their entire catalog around.
Within travel, hotels are among the categories members most want to redeem against, alongside vacation rentals, air travel, car rentals, tours and activities, and cruise. The snapshot doesn't support a clean rank order across all six, so treat that as a set of strong candidates rather than a leaderboard.2
One caveat worth holding onto: stated interest is not booked volume. Survey respondents are generous with their enthusiasm. But an 83-to-40 gap is wide enough that even a heavy discount on self-reported intent leaves travel well in front.
Why Gift Cards Lose the Loyalty Rewards Redemption Race
Gift cards and merchandise underperform because they turn every redemption into a price comparison, and the program usually loses it. When a member sees a $25 gift card listed at 5,000 points, they know exactly what a point is worth. Half a cent. Then they think about what their cash-back card pays, and the reward starts to feel small.
Merchandise has the same problem with an extra step. The member opens a second tab, finds the same speaker on a major retail site, and does the division. Catalog pricing rarely survives that math, because it has to cover fulfillment, shipping, and the margin of whoever runs the catalog.
Travel doesn't get judged the same way. A hotel night in a city the member keeps meaning to visit isn't a line item in this month's budget. It lives in the someday column, and points are what move it to this spring. The member isn't comparing the redemption to cash they would have spent anyway. They're comparing it to not taking the trip.
That difference matters because perceived value drives loyalty rewards redemption more than the math does. Deloitte's 2025 survey found that overall value is the top reason consumers join a new loyalty program, ranked ahead of ongoing benefits and sign-up incentives. When a program delivers that value, behavior follows: 72% of consumers say loyalty programs make them more likely to spend with their preferred brand, and 56% say they spend more because of the program.3
One piece of fine print. Deloitte asked its behavior questions about each respondent's favorite program, so those numbers describe programs that are already earning attention. That's sort of the point. A program earns that spot by making members feel the value, not by making them do arithmetic.
None of this means gift cards should disappear. They're a perfectly good floor. A member with a small balance still needs somewhere to spend it, and a gift card beats an expiration notice. The mistake is treating the floor as the whole building.
Hotel Points Redemption: Why Hotels Stopped Treating Points as a Rebate
The supply side figured this out first, and it changed how they think about the currency.
Speaking to Today's Hotelier, Wyndham's Michael Shiwdin, Group VP of Loyalty and Partnerships, put it plainly: "Points and free nights still matter, but loyalty today is about influencing decisions, not just rewarding past stays."1 That's a meaningful shift in posture. A rebate looks backward at a transaction that already happened. A demand driver looks forward at one that hasn't.
The membership numbers moved with it. The same article cites CBRE data showing hotel loyalty program membership grew 14.5% in 2024, and Wyndham says nearly half of all its check-ins now come from Wyndham Rewards members.1
Hotel points redemption also appears to change behavior, not just discount it. Hilton Honors VP Brad Anderson pointed to "58 percent reporting that they use loyalty points to try new properties, activities, and destinations."1 Points aren't just subsidizing stays members were already going to book. Often they're buying the stay a member wouldn't have risked at cash price, which is exactly the behavior a program owner should want to fund.
There's a second lesson in how the big programs describe their members. Marriott's Chief Customer Officer, Peggy Roe, described a split: some travelers collect points to redeem, others care more about access and recognition, and some want all of it.1 Even one of the largest hotel programs in the world isn't assuming a single motivation covers its membership. A credit union or association shouldn't either. The member who wants a free night and the member who wants to feel like an insider can be served by the same hotel inventory. They just won't respond to the same message.
Wyndham's Shiwdin also offered a useful filter for any redemption partner, hotel or otherwise. Partners should be simple to understand, worth something real to guests, and make economic sense for owners.1 Run your current catalog through that filter. Most of it clears the third test and fails the first two.
Points Redemption for Theme Parks and Attractions
Experiential redemption has moved from novelty to table stakes at the top of the market. Hilton has built Honors Adventures partnerships with operators including AutoCamp and Explora Journeys. Marriott, as Official Hotel Supporter of the 2026 FIFA World Cup, is making points redeemable for tickets and experiences around the tournament.1
Be clear about what that evidence is and isn't. There's no solid public data on attraction or theme park redemption volume, and nobody should be quoting a growth rate for it. What we have is directional: the programs with the most sophisticated redemption analytics are all building in the same direction at once. It’s one of the clearest signs of how travel is transforming points redemption in loyalty programs.
Points redemption for theme parks is where that logic bites hardest, because a park ticket is a high-consideration purchase with a real cash price attached. A member who covers a family's park day with points has gotten something they can describe to other people. A $15 gift card does not generate that conversation.
Timing works in the program's favor, too. Park trips get planned weeks or months out, usually around school calendars, which gives a points balance a natural deadline and gives the program a natural reason to show up in a member's inbox. "You have enough points for two park tickets this summer" is an email people open. "Your points balance has been updated" is not.
Why the Redemption Experience Decides Your Redemption Rate
You can assemble the right catalog and still lose. The interface is where good inventory goes to die.
Deloitte's 2025 Consumer Loyalty Program Survey, covering 5,564 US loyalty members, found that "40% of all respondents admit to sometimes forgetting to redeem."3 Not "chose not to." Forgot. Two in five members have earned a balance and let it sit, and Deloitte's own recommendation is that redemption should feel like a seamless transaction rather than a separate errand.
That's a redemption experience problem, and it feeds directly into your redemption rate. The same research found that the average consumer enrolls in eight programs but actively participates in five, and that 51% engage with only one program within a given industry.3 The programs that go dormant aren't usually the ones with bad rewards. They're the ones where getting to the reward required more steps than the reward was worth.
Travel redemption raises the stakes here, because booking is inherently more complex than picking a gift card off a grid. If a member has to leave your environment, create a second account, and decipher a separate inventory system, you've reintroduced every point of friction you just spent money removing.
Deloitte's data also shows redemption habits split by age. Younger consumers are more likely to redeem promptly, while unplanned redemptions are more common among older generations.3 That gives a single redemption flow two jobs. It has to be fast for the member who redeems the moment they hit a threshold, and visible for the member who only redeems when something prompts them. A balance reminder tied to a specific, bookable reward does more for that second group than any redesign of the rewards page.
What's a Good Redemption Rate for a Loyalty Program?
There isn't a credible industry benchmark, and anyone publishing one is usually selling something adjacent to it. Redemption rates vary enormously by currency design, earn velocity, and catalog value, so a cross-industry average tells you almost nothing about your own program. Track your own trend instead: what share of active members redeem at least once per year, and how long it takes a new member to go from first earn to first burn. Those two lines moving in the right direction matter more than any published figure.
Travel tends to move those two lines in different directions, and that's worth knowing before you panic. A hotel stay or a park day gives members a goal worth saving loyalty points toward, which can stretch the time between first earn and first burn while making each redemption bigger and more memorable. That trade is usually a good one. What you're watching for is the member who sets a goal and stalls, which is where a nudge showing exactly how close they are earns its keep.
Do Unredeemed Points Help or Hurt a Program?
Both, depending on which column you're reading. Breakage looks good on the balance sheet. Unredeemed points are a liability that may never come due, and it’s exactly the kind of loyalty program points liability your CFO should care about. But Deloitte's finding that 40% of members sometimes forget to redeem suggests those balances often belong to people who are quietly drifting away.3 Finance and marketing reasonably weigh this differently, and neither is being unreasonable. The question is whether your breakage is a margin cushion or an early warning.
One practical way to split the difference is to sort balances by recency. Loyalty points held by a member who earned last month are savings for a future trip. Loyalty points held by a member who hasn't logged in for a year are a goodbye note that hasn't been mailed yet. Same liability on the balance sheet. Very different conversation for the marketing team.
You Don't Have to Be a Travel Brand to Offer Loyalty Points for Travel
The demand is portable, which is the part most program owners underestimate. Expedia Group found that 82% of consumers are interested in booking travel through a non-travel loyalty program they belong to, and 43% are very or extremely interested. 67% say they'd book through one if they could redeem points for it, and 68% say they would if they could earn points on it.2
Members are not demanding that their credit union become an online travel agency. They're saying that if the inventory is there and the points work, they'll use it.
Trust decides whether that interest turns into bookings. When Expedia asked where consumers are most likely to book travel, a travel provider they know and trust came first. Second was a trusted non-travel provider, like a credit card or retailer, powered by a well-known travel brand. A trusted non-travel provider on its own ranked third, and an unfamiliar one came last.2 Read that ranking from a program owner's seat and it's good news. Your members already trust you. The job isn't to become a travel brand. It's to put recognizable travel inventory behind a name they already know.
This matters most for credit unions, banks, associations, and any organization running a points currency on top of a relationship that has nothing to do with travel. Those programs tend to have the most member trust and the least exciting catalog. The gap between how much members like the organization and how little they want from its rewards store is exactly where travel redemption earns its keep.
How to Build Travel Points Redemption Into a Non-Travel Program
Adding travel points redemption to a program that isn't built around travel comes down to a handful of decisions most programs make by accident: what a point is worth, whether points can mix with cash, whose name is on the booking experience, how prices compare to public sites, and who handles service. Get those right and the inventory does most of the selling.
Give points a value members can explain. If a point buys half a cent in gift cards and a full cent in hotel nights, members will notice, and they'll feel managed instead of rewarded. A consistent value across categories is easier to market and harder to resent. If travel is going to be the better deal, make it better on purpose and say so.
Let points and cash work together. A member sitting on 6,000 points shouldn't be locked out of a hotel night because the full redemption costs 30,000. Partial redemption keeps small balances useful, and a useful balance is a lot harder to forget about. With 40% of members admitting they sometimes forget to redeem, that's not a small thing.3
Keep the experience under your name. Expedia's trust ranking points one direction: members prefer booking with a provider they know, backed by travel brands they recognize.2 Sending them to a third-party site with a different logo and a new login spends that trust instead of using it.
Price against what members can find on their own. Members will check. A points redemption that comes out worse than booking the same room on a public site isn't a reward. It's a tax on loyalty. Private or members-only rates matter here because they give the program a price the member can't find by opening another tab.
Market the burn, not just the earn. Most program communication celebrates earning. Balance updates, bonus point promotions, tier progress. Redemption gets a button at the bottom of the page. Flip some of that attention. Show members what their current balance can book, with real destinations and real dates. A balance is abstract. A long weekend at the beach is not.
Decide who answers the phone. Travel redemption is operationally heavier than a gift-card catalog. Inventory shifts, rates move, cancellations and service issues land somewhere, and somebody has to own the support call when a booking goes wrong. That's a real cost, and it's why most programs default to the easy catalog even when they know it underperforms.
That operational weight is the problem Access Development solves. Access gives members a white-labeled travel and attractions platform with 850,000+ hotels and 120+ theme parks, water parks, attractions, and tours, all at private rates not available on public booking sites. Hotel rates run below sites like Expedia and Booking.com, and park and attraction tickets run below public pricing. The park inventory is the hard part to replicate. Access is one of only a handful of authorized resellers integrated directly with Disney and Universal ticketing, which isn't a relationship a mid-sized loyalty program can assemble on its own. Access also provides 24/7 support for member travel bookings, so the support call doesn't land on your team.
The Bottom Line
Points are inert until they're spent. Every balance sitting in an account is a promise the member hasn't cashed, and a member who never cashes it eventually stops earning it. What they want to cash it for is no longer a mystery. Travel leads by a wide margin, and the hotel brands repositioned their entire loyalty posture around that fact.
The members already enrolled in your program are the ones this decision affects. They're the file you've already paid for.
If your catalog is still built around gift cards and drinkware, start there. Swap the travel mug for something a member would actually tell someone about.
Endnotes/Resources
Topics: Customer Engagement, Discount Programs, ecommerce, customer retention, customer loyalty, loyalty programs
Written by: Ryan Marvel



Share your Comment.